When I told her that I was reading Tender is the Night, Kelli warned me that it was 'terrible'. She'd abandoned it because of it's 'old-fashioned' writing. At that point, I was about 20 pages in, and I told her that I thought it was great so far. And I did end up liking it, but it sure wasn't the story I thought I was getting when I started reading it.
I enjoy Fitzgerald's writing; his descriptive passages are so evocative that they seem like pictures instead of words. I could almost feel the oppressive stillness of the night in this description, "It was a limpid black night, hung as in a basket from a single dull star." I also like his au courant syntax. Young people's feelings of rootlessness and restlessness in post WWI Europe are pefectly captured in his writing.
Tender is the Night opens in the summer of 1925 with Rosemary, a young American actress, arriving at a Mediterranean resort and meeting the Divers, Dick and Nicole. Impressionable and unexperienced, Rosemary soon finds herself falling in love with the carefree, fun-loving, patrician Divers, especially Dick. Over the next 129 pages, Fitzgerald develops a Rosemary into a very likable protagonist, and develops the relationship between Dick and her to the point of crisis - Dick is also in love with Rosemary, but will he betray Nicole?
On page 130, Fitzgerald throws us a huge curveball. Suddenly we're in Zurich in the spring of 1917, and we're learning how Dick and Nicole met. At this point, I presumed that this back story was needed to further build the dilemma that Dick was facing. But I was wrong. Turns out, this story isn't about Rosemary, it's about Dick and Nicole. Rosemary was a device Fitzgerald used to introduce the appearance of the Divers before explaining the reality of the Divers. And it turns out, Dick isn't such a nice guy. And it turns out, Nicole is anything but carefree.
I had a really hard time readjusting my perspective when the story changed. I had far too much invested in Rosemary to easily give up on her story. And maybe that's why I came to so dislike Dick. Although Dick appears to be a charming, loving guy, he turns out to be an ethically challenged parasite who is using Nicole for her money and as a cover for his lack of career advancement. As time goes on, Dick is less and less able to maintain his charming facade. By the end of the novel, he has been shunned by his former circle of friends, as he so richly deserves.
Rosemary returns in a supporting role near the end of the book, and - perhaps because she's so closely associated with Dick, or perhaps because she's no longer an innocent - she is far less likable.
The book has a big surprise, which I haven't revealed here. It's that surprise (hint - it involves Nicole) that ultimately redeems this book and makes it worth the read.
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
1/4 of the Way - from Kelli
Phew. Skating in barely before my winter break ended (literally, 30 minutes before my "school days" bedtime), I finished "In Cold Blood" - which is the best book I've read so far in this challenge. Perhaps because I'm a sucker for crime stories, but also because Truman Capote's ability to realistically recreate feelings, thoughts, and images is astounding. If you haven't read it - stop reading this post and go buy it.
"Catch-22" ended up being pretty great. The last 160 pages of the novel went much more quickly than the first 300. It just took some stamina and determination. I think the reason the book was so hard to read for me was because Joseph Heller's writing presents its own imaginative, wonderful logic. The irrationality of the book (a reflection, I believe, of Heller's view on war) made it difficult to read chapter by chapter. You really have to get into the mindframe of the book - a challenge when you're only reading 20 or 30 pages each time before you hit the sack. My recommendation for the book: pick a time when you have nothing to do all day and power through it. The book is a delightful challenge to the American status-quo and will leave you feeling satisfied.
This year, Caitlin, Marie and I (Caitlin and I currently at 25 books a piece, and Marie at 27) need to keep a pace of approximately 1 book for every 2 weeks to keep on track for a 2014 finish date. My mother, however, can take a more leisurely approach (especially considering she's been reading as fast as I have!). She needs only 56 more books to declare victory!
Summary scoring of 2011 books:
"Slaughterhouse Five": A+++ (this is the book, never blogged about, that actually roused my interest in partaking of the challenge)
"Lord of the Flies": B-
"Franny and Zooey": C
"In Our Time": B+
"Catch-22": B
"In Cold Blood": A++
Sunday, January 1, 2012
"The Portrait of a Lady" - Caitlin's Thoughts
This is the most I have ever struggled with any book and if it weren't for the challenge, I would have put it down by page 35 (of 548).
GENERAL IMPRESSIONS: Blech, blech, and more blech. If Henry James' goal was to make you want to punch the heroine of the book only slightly less than you want to kill it's author, than he was immensely successful. I am frustrated in real life by people who are determined to be unhappy and the book puts them on a pedestal. The titular character, the lady- Isabel Archer, shows promise in her first introduction as she is intelligent, independent, and unabashedly American. But then James starts heaping on insanely boring and annoying descriptions of personality traits as the minimalistic plot requires them to give him something to write about. Every single thing I wanted to happen in this book didn't. Plus, when something was actually interesting, James spent an uncharacteristically short amount of time describing it (the loss of an infant child is mentioned in a fleeting half sentence while the way the main character turns the page of a book is granted a full chapter of description). Essentially, this was everything I don't like (too much description, unrelatable characters, non-existent plotlines, and self-imposed angst) all in one book. Besides the obvious outdatedness of the book (wasting away illnesses making people "invalids", lords/ladies, dutiful wives, children being raised at convents, shocking age differences in marriages, etc...) there was one modern concept which still exists in other books on the list which frustrate me (i.e. On the Road)- an obnoxious preoccupation by characters with their self-imposed unhappiness. Just makes me want to punch them all.
GENERAL IMPRESSIONS: Blech, blech, and more blech. If Henry James' goal was to make you want to punch the heroine of the book only slightly less than you want to kill it's author, than he was immensely successful. I am frustrated in real life by people who are determined to be unhappy and the book puts them on a pedestal. The titular character, the lady- Isabel Archer, shows promise in her first introduction as she is intelligent, independent, and unabashedly American. But then James starts heaping on insanely boring and annoying descriptions of personality traits as the minimalistic plot requires them to give him something to write about. Every single thing I wanted to happen in this book didn't. Plus, when something was actually interesting, James spent an uncharacteristically short amount of time describing it (the loss of an infant child is mentioned in a fleeting half sentence while the way the main character turns the page of a book is granted a full chapter of description). Essentially, this was everything I don't like (too much description, unrelatable characters, non-existent plotlines, and self-imposed angst) all in one book. Besides the obvious outdatedness of the book (wasting away illnesses making people "invalids", lords/ladies, dutiful wives, children being raised at convents, shocking age differences in marriages, etc...) there was one modern concept which still exists in other books on the list which frustrate me (i.e. On the Road)- an obnoxious preoccupation by characters with their self-imposed unhappiness. Just makes me want to punch them all.
SPOILER ALERTS: The most action of the book occurs in the last 55 pages. You'll want to gouge your eyes out with the corner of your book until then.
MUSINGS: Why are my favorite characters consistently referred to as "simple"? Complex people can be happy too. Suck it, Henry James. Also, this book shouldn't even be on this list because it was written in the 19th century.
GRADE SHEET:
Narrator's Likability: F
Pace: D-
Readability: C
Satisfying Ending: B-
Impressively Long Paragraphs: A
Use of French: B+ (I understood most of it without translations! Which was good because my book didn't have any...)
Thursday, December 29, 2011
"Catch-22" from Kelli
Reading Catch-22 is a Catch-22. It's not good enough to want to keep reading, but its not bad enough to want to stop reading. Out of the 450 pages there are to get through, I'm at 302 after reading for over two weeks! Usually, things do not take me the long. Especially when I'm on winter-freaking-break.
The short chapters, which I thought would make it easier to read, have proven to be excuses for me to stop reading after only a few pages each night - slowing my pace down tremendously. The book is picking up a bit - since approx. page 250, so hopefully these last 150 pages will start flowing. You'll get my full report soon (I think). Maybe Catch-22 was the wrong choice for the end of the year. I still need to finish this book AND another before the new year. Wish me luck!
Sunday, December 11, 2011
"Lord of the Flies" from Kelli
I was the only one who hadn't read "Lord of the Flies" yet. Apparently it's a high school classic that I avoided at all costs so I wouldn't appear "mainstream" in my high school reading for pleasure class. Perhaps I should have read it in high school, because the novel is so impactful and has been for generations.
William Golding's symbolism is beautiful and timely (the book was published in 1954) and clearly reflects his own dissatisfaction with the current results of the human experiment with democracy and governing. In my estimation, Golding is like an earlier, less sardonic version of Kurt Vonnegut who comments on and critiques our society through this brief, but dense allegorical story.
In my brief research into the book, I found that it was not originally a success and went out of print shortly after its initial publication date. In the 60s though, the book rapidly gained popularity and has since been on three different "short lists" of the best novels of the 20th century. Perhaps the book was more appreciated in the 60s due to the rising anti-war sentiments in the Western world.
If you, like me, didn't find this book on your high school reading list, don't hesitate to add it to your current reading list,
"In Our Time" from Kelli
I hated Hemingway in high school. I found him to be a pompous, womanizing, uninteresting pile of shit. It turns out, he is pompous and womanizing, but he's actually quite interesting and his writing is understated, but beautiful.
About 60 pages in, I misplaced the book for 2 weeks and so I opted to pick up Franny and Zooey to continue my trek toward 100. When I thought all was lost and was ready to order the Kindle edition so I could keep going, I found it in the crevice of my couch and finished the book within the week.
My favorite story is the third to last in the book (the stories get better as you go on, so the end of the book held all of the jewels) called "My Old Man". It is written from the point of view of a small boy who idolizes his father, who is a jockey. The prose is so descriptive I was sure Hemingway had some experience with horse racing when he was younger. As it turns out, he did not, so I went in search of some other experience he may have had that shaped this wonderful story. What I found was that, for a short period of time right out of high school, Hemingway had a job as a journalist for the Kansas City Star and modeled his initial writings off of a sports writer he admired. His famously to-the-point style was taken directly from his first days as a journalist where he learned: "Use short sentences. Use short first paragraphs. Use vigorous English. Be positive, not negative."
Although I was initially tiffed that so many Hemingway novels were on the top 100 list (because of my deep-seated hatred), I'm now looking forward to reading more of his work. As long as he continues to be a straight-shooter, he's a-OK with me.
Thursday, December 8, 2011
Defeated by "On the Road" - Lynn
I just can't do it yet. I am supposed to have been reading On the Road by Jack Kerouac, but I can't. This is the second time I've attempted to read this book. The first time I got about thirty dogged, molasses, slo-mo pages in and couldn't proceed. This time, with memories of the first slog in my mind, I gave up after a page.
Here's the thing: Jack Kerouac is a smug, self-satisfied, ass. Of the most detestable, sexist kind. What might have been hip in the 1950s, daddy-o, is insufferable in the 21st century. Even his first, flip, sentence is a turn off, "I first met Dean not long after my wife and I split up."
I'll bet they split up. I'll bet they split up because he was an insufferable boor who needed to be on the road because no one could put up with him for very long.
I'm going to have to be pushing a 100 books - goal well within reach - to be able to suffer this nowheresville drag.
Here's the thing: Jack Kerouac is a smug, self-satisfied, ass. Of the most detestable, sexist kind. What might have been hip in the 1950s, daddy-o, is insufferable in the 21st century. Even his first, flip, sentence is a turn off, "I first met Dean not long after my wife and I split up."
I'll bet they split up. I'll bet they split up because he was an insufferable boor who needed to be on the road because no one could put up with him for very long.
I'm going to have to be pushing a 100 books - goal well within reach - to be able to suffer this nowheresville drag.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)